The Best Supernatural Games for Playstation 4

Update 30 December 2023: Midnight Suns added at rank #20.

Nintendo Switch Xbox Series X Playstation 5 Mac OS Xbox One Playstation 4 PC Windows Xbox Series X/s

Step into the shoes of Atma in A Space for the Unbound, a heartwarming adventure set in 90s rural Indonesia. Discover hidden secrets, interact with townsfolk, and solve intriguing puzzles in this nostalgic and supernatural experience. Immerse yourself in the captivating pixel art graphics and soothing music.

• Engaging and charming storyline
• Relaxing and simple gameplay
• Stunning pixel art graphics
• Well-designed puzzles
• Beautiful and calming soundtrack

• Repetitive combat sequences
• Confusing and unhelpful map
• Excessive back-and-forth exploration

• supernatural
• pixel
• 1990s
• philosophical
• story
• surreal
• adventure
• emotional
• anime
• psychological
• narrative
• puzzle
• mystery
• walking-simulator
• dystopian

Good match + 14 Bad match - 20

Android IOS iPhone Nintendo Switch PC Windows Playstation 4 Playstation 5 Mac OS

Uncover a sinister plot in OXENFREE II: Lost Signals as you navigate the mysterious town of Camena. With engaging characters, a captivating story, and your choices shaping the narrative, this game promises a thrilling adventure. Use your walkie talkie to tap into ghostly signals and manipulate time. Will you save the future or ignore those in need? The choice is yours.

• Engaging characters
• Captivating story twists
• Excellent dialogue system
• Satisfying conclusion
• Beautiful art style

• Minimal presence of other characters
• Time travel aspect lacks impact
• Easy to miss side stories

• supernatural
• horror
• narrative
• cult
• mystery
• puzzle
• adventure
• choices
• story
• interactive
• exploration
• local

Good match + 3 Bad match

Playstation 5 Playstation 4 PC Windows Xbox Series X Xbox One stadia Nintendo Switch IOS iPhone

Experience a bold new era in the award-winning Life is Strange series with Life is Strange: True Colors. Uncover the shocking secrets behind your brother's death as you navigate through an emotional roller-coaster of an adventure. Harness the power of Empathy to change fate and forge deep relationships with the townsfolk. Make tough decisions, explore the vibrant town of Haven Springs, and discover your own voice. With a captivating story, unforgettable characters, and an exclusive soundtrack, this game is a must-play.

• Beautiful graphics and realistic scenery
• Engaging slice-of-life gameplay
• Unique power to control emotions
• Realistic portrayal of difficult topics
• Enjoyable romance options

• Predictable plot and lack of impactful choices
• Episodes feel rushed and underdeveloped
• Limited character interaction after emotional moments
• Short gameplay and shallow character relationships

• narrative
• episodic
• supernatural
• mystery
• story
• choices
• drama
• adventure
• romance
• local
• puzzle
• romantic
• difficult

Good match + 35 Bad match - 61

Playstation 4 Android Xbox Series X Nintendo Switch Playstation 5 stadia PC Windows Xbox One

Step into the enigmatic world of Control Ultimate Edition, where you wield otherworldly powers and fight through a shape-shifting building. Unravel a dark, gripping narrative and engage in exhilarating combat, using telekinesis and transformable weaponry to restore order against an otherworldly threat. Discover secrets, earn upgrades, and become the master of this reality-bending adventure!

• Gripping narrative
• Innovative combat mechanics
• Expansive world with hidden secrets
• Stunning visuals and environmental effects
• Included DLC enhances the experience

• Saves not transferable between console generations
• Can be challenging for some

• supernatural
• tps
• story
• shooter
• narrative
• third-person
• horror
• sci-fi
• combat
• metroidvania
• action-adventure
• exploration
• action
• boss-fight
• battle

Good match + 53 Bad match - 70

PC Windows Nintendo Switch Xbox One Linux Mac OS IOS iPhone Playstation 4

Get lost in the magical world of Mutazione, a narrative-driven adventure game where you explore an island filled with quirky mutant characters and their secrets. Grow musical gardens, attend BBQs, and embark on a spiritual journey to save the community from a looming darkness. With beautiful hand-illustrated art and unpredictable twists, Mutazione is a mutant soap opera that you won't want to miss.

• Unique and beautiful art style
• Relaxing music
• Story-focused gameplay
• Quirky and interesting characters
• Encourages the player to slow down and relax

• Repetitive gameplay, mostly a visual novel
• No voice acting
• Slow parts may be boring for some players
• Contains adult themes that may not be suitable for younger children

• drama
• narrative
• supernatural
• relaxing
• adventure
• walking-simulator
• point-and-click
• nature
• exploration
• fiction
• music
• story
• scroller
• bird
• procedural

Good match + 53 Bad match - 99

PC Windows Xbox One Playstation 5 Playstation 4 stadia Nintendo Switch Linux Mac OS IOS iPhone

Join Detectives McQueen and Dooley as they solve six different cases full of humour and great references in the town of Twin Lakes. With beautiful retro-style pixel graphics, this is a must play for lovers of cats, coffee and all kinds of videogames!

• Crisp and clean pixel graphics
• Variety in music
• Sense of satisfaction when solving a case
• Humourous atmosphere
• Great movie references

• Cases are straightforward
• Not super challenging
• No tries to scare you

• point-and-click
• detective
• supernatural
• pixel
• adventure
• funny
• retro
• mystery
• puzzle
• comedy

Good match + 52 Bad match - 95

Mac OS IOS iPhone PC Windows Playstation 4 Nintendo Switch

The ground starts shaking, light bulbs are breaking - and something rather unusual is happening right behind the walls of your very room. Equipped with nothing but wit and courage, you slowly descend into a world inhabited by avian folk and seemingly deadly furniture monsters.

• hand-drawn
• puzzle
• surreal
• stylized
• supernatural
• platform
• atmospheric
• linear
• cartoony
• relaxing
• 2d
• mystery
• story
• dark
• single-player

Good match + 3 Bad match - 5

PC Windows Xbox Series X/s Playstation 4 Xbox One Xbox Series X Playstation 5

Weird West is an action-heavy isometric story-based game with a unique Western horror twist and immersive sim mechanics. You play as a former bounty hunter in search of vengeance, travelling across deserts, swamps, towns, and mines to uncover dark secrets and ultimately save the West from destruction.

• Flexible scope with plenty of replay value
• Deep world with memorable characters
• Dark humor and darker secrets to uncover
• Shifts and changes with the passage of time
• Combines action shooter elements with RPG and immersive sim mechanics

• Combat can be overly convoluted when using controller

• stealth
• isometric
• rpg
• twin-stick
• supernatural
• western
• shooter
• combat
• top-down
• action
• narrative
• simulation
• fantasy
• zombies
• cover

Good match + 1 Bad match - 1

Linux Mac OS Nintendo Switch Playstation 4 Xbox One PC Windows

Guide radio hosts Poe and Munro through six episodes of supernatural FMV adventure in the strange town of August! From the creators of award winning FMV games The Infectious Madness of Doctor Dekker and The Shapeshifting Detective.

• supernatural
• choices
• fmv
• episodic
• fiction
• cinematic
• interactive
• mystery
• horror
• detective
• investigation
• multiple-endings
• telltale
• comedy
• drama

Good match + 18 Bad match - 37

Playstation 4 Xbox One PC Windows Playstation 5 Xbox Series X/s

Winner of over 80 awards, Control is a visually stunning third-person action-adventure that will keep you on the edge of your seat.

• supernatural
• horror
• story
• narrative
• tps
• boss-fight
• third-person
• sci-fi
• shooter
• action-adventure
• combat
• action
• fight
• puzzle

Good match + 20 Bad match - 46

Not seeing your game? Click here to add it!

Thanks a lot for your contribution.

ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7dnzGmqSeq5yeuKZ6wqikaJqVqMFus8CmnKxlkq56tcXPnmasraCav6%2Bt066pmqRfpcB1